Rankings Reflect Optimism for Older Males' Comeback in 2025

The older dirt male division has faced challenges over the past two seasons, following Flightline's dominant performance in the 2022 Breeders’ Cup Classic. The division has struggled with premature retirements, injuries, and a lack of depth, leading to underwhelming performances. However, there is renewed hope for 2025 as several standout 3-year-olds may transition into this category, potentially revitalising its competitive spirit. 

Looking at this week’s rankings, National Treasure is likely an Eclipse Award recipient, boasting two major Grade 1 wins and near victories in other significant races. Despite injury setbacks, Subsanador and Newgate showed promise earlier in the season. Newgate has now retired, leaving space for contenders like Highland Falls, whose inconsistent performances culminated in a disappointing Breeders’ Cup Classic run. Hit Show has also had mixed results, with underwhelming recent performances dimming an otherwise strong season. 

The rankings of older dirt females also highlight notable retirements. Idiomatic and Adare Manor dominated with Grade 1 victories but won’t return next season. Meanwhile, Raging Sea and Randomized displayed solid, if inconsistent, efforts, and Sweet Azteca had a surprising stumble late in the season. 

Among 3-year-olds, Sierra Leone and Fierceness stand out, with the former’s Breeders’ Cup Classic victory securing top billing. Similarly, Thorpedo Anna shines among 3-year-old fillies, but benefited from weaker competition in her division. 

With new talent and established performers, 2025 could mark a turning point for these categories, provided injuries and retirements don’t hinder the competition further.